Raise your hand if you know about Andrew Carnegie. For those of you who don’t, he was a steel magnate who amassed a fortune during the 1800s that would be worth more than $250 billion in today’s dollars. To put this in perspective, Carnegie would have more money than the top three richest men today, combined.
Carnegie brutally cut through conventions, competitors, and people in his way when he wanted to achieve an objective. For example, during his twenties, he worked for the Pennsylvania railroad and set a stalled train car on fire to prevent further delays on the railroad. Let me repeat that. He set fire to an expensive piece of machinery to prevent delays…
While his coworkers picked their jaws up from the ground, the top executives at the Pennsylvania railroad discovered that Carnegie was right! Destroying the train car was much more efficient than fixing it.
But how ironic is that? The world’s largest corporation (in 1800s) handled one of their biggest problems the wrong way until some punk-kid named Andy changed everything. Now, here is what you can learn from Carnegie’s maverick-like experience:
Discover Your True Objective
After a train crash, railroad executives had one main objective and it was to prevent further delays. Prior to Carnegie, they prevented further delays in a roundabout way — fix the train and move it out of the way. However, Carnegie broke the task down to its core — prevent delays — and skipped everything in between.
Focus on Your Actions (not your explanations)
If Carnegie proposed “burn the train” to the senior management at Pennsylvania railroad, they would have laughed in his face. Why would they want to destroy an expensive piece of machinery? However, when Carnegie did it without permission, the senior management skipped over whether the decision was logical and decided whether it was efficient and in this case, it was very efficient.
Please note, I’m not telling you to burn or destroy anything. I am using Carnegie’s experience as an example.
Destroy Existing Standards (and Create New Ones)
Carnegie loved best practices, but he realized that there was a point where you needed to tear down existing standards and create some new ones. When he burned that first train car, he destroyed an established best-practice of fixing the broken trains. This was a major risk, but it made sense and it became a new best practice. Now, just remember, today’s conventions were yesterday’s innovations, so ensure that you do something today to innovate.
What Do You Think?
Do you know any other Andrew Carnegie stories? Do you think these tactics still apply today? Leave some comments!
Do you know someone who will enjoy this article? Don’t forget to send it to a friend!


{ 14 comments… read them below or add one }
Too many people get caught up with what they have to do and rush to do it. With Carnegie, it looks like he would look at things without that burning desire to just finish and instead looked to improve.
Great stuff derek!
Carnegie was a Maverick of the best kind. He didn’t make that choice to burn a car without thought. He probably thought long and hard then realized that he really only had one choice.
I’m trying to think of ways that I’ve burned my proverbial “railroad car.” I guess the closest I came to it was when I was blogging under my name and had a decent audience. I decided to change and start my present blog. I knew it was a smart choice even though I would lose a lot of momentum.
Derek, do you have a “railroad car” that you had to burn?
Derek,
This sounds like a great blog series.
Carnegie was a man of action. He made a decision and acted on it. The definition of power is the speed of particle flow. A fast boat has power. A bomb goes off the particles move fast, that is power. Carnegie acted fast. Not lots of think or discussion involved.
Sheila
@Karl I think the railroad car that I had to burn would have been my lazieness. One of the reasons I started working a full-time job was because I wasn’t being productive with my time as an entrepreneur. This is why I did the reverse dreams — make money on the internet and then move to full-time work.
@Sheila He sure did act fast. In almost all cases, when he saw an opportunity, he hopped on it as fast as possible and put all of his effort into it. It’s quite inspiring.
Derek, I recently read Carnegie’s autobiography and got a lot out of it. Another lesson:
Don’t dwell on the negatives.
Carnegie wrote: “It is folly to cross a bridge before you come to it, or bid the Devil good morning until you meet him — perfect folly. All is well until the stroke falls, and even then nine times out of ten it is not so bad as anticipated. A wise man is the confirmed optimist.” good advice, especially in these times.
@Anita that is a great excerpt. There are too many people who get caught up with why they shouldn’t do something and they never even try to do it…
Nice write-up Derek. To add to what u’ve wrote Carnegie was a man of his time, and was aware of that. Therefore was prepared, – which leads to one of my fav quotes; Chance favours the prepared.
@ace thanks. Was chance favours the prepared a Carnegie quote?
I love the robber barons because they were not robbers. I have a lot of respect for them or other self-made individuals. I’ve made it a practice since 5 years-old, the earliest memories I have, to not ask permission. More often than not it serves me well. Very few people have the balls anymore to take decisive action. Interestingly enough I think part of the reason is the connectivity of everyone. You can reach a supervisor anywhere in the world at any time and ask. In the old days people had to decide for themselves. We have become a bunch of wimpy permission whores.
Sorry, I guess I’m in a mood today.
When you start burning railroad cars people take notice. If makes you better, faster, and cheaper. the will try and stop you. accuse you of arson. New faster better that is real scares the crap out of people.
We now live a world where the more you have the more percentage you pay in taxes. Only socialism believes one should pay a higher percent in taxes for working harder. So well, the more money you make, the more you should pay at the pumps also? When the PEOPLE wake up, send me a post card. Carnegie is turning in his grave.
thank you for this information on Mr Carnegie
WE NEED SOME BAD FACTS PLEASE JIMMY!
right on big joe, i understand if we cant find good facts on this website, where will we find them.. but its derrick, not jimmy…
{ 1 trackback }